rate_review Reviews

Each one of these chapters always seems to end with a dissertation of the many, many elements you add in. I really do like your stories, this one especially for its ingenuity, length, and class, but I have to wonder, how do you find the time to think up all the stuff you put in each chapter, let alone find 'em? As it has been since I started this sometime last year, and as I suspect it will be until its proper and just end, this has a pleasure to read.

=D
this is songbird13.
i posted my challenge because i can't get enough of your story and there aren't any more out there like it!!
YOU'RE doing a fantastic job.

Lol, sorry I didn't mean to sound criticising in my previous review. I do love your work though, it's not often one finds a fanficiton with so much thought put into plot and character development, and the story seems to grow more and more in depth and interesting with each chapter. It's clear you really do your research, I got to say it's pretty amazing to see, most people don't usually put so much effort in, but it really adds something to the story. Anyways, look forward to reading more.

Erm - only got so far, so not sure if you've explained or mentioned this already, but you said Charlie's parents couldn't marry in England as they were cousins. In England cousins are legally allowed to marry so it doesn't make much sense as a reason.

This is a wonderful look at Wonka's backstory! It really feels as though you can see the enthusiastic young Willy just out to make friends and some delectable treats. You do a magnificent job covering all of the facts and research from other inspirations as well. Well done! Can't wait to read more! :-)

This is honestly one of the best fanfics we have ever read...The time and effort you put into this story really shows. In every historical, literary, and pop-culture reference you make, you make a brilliant example of the skill and dedication required to make VERY good fanfiction. It isn't just references though. You have a very unique and readable voice in your work that makes it able to be read over and over. (That's very rare lately) There's more, but we couldn't possibly think of it all.
We're proud to call "Is It Scary" our favorite fanfic of all time. Thank you.
-T.A.

PS: We know how it is to live off reviews. Hope you find the inspiration you need to continue making this one of the best there's ever been.

Oooo! update soon please! I was afraid you had forgotten this story!

OMG!!! So I don't know how late this review is gonna be because I'm too lazy to check the date...I LOVE this story!!!! I started reading it a while ago and then sort of forgot about it (mostly because I stopped reading CatCF) but I found it again and I got to read all of it (well what you have) and seriously this is the bomb! I really hope that you update soon!! Seriously though... <3<3<3

D

My word this is fabulous! This is the best Charlie/Wonka story i have ever read, and it is so detailed and well thought out. Every once in a while i catch a nuance or hidden meaning thinking that it is just a coincedence but it ends up being intentional everytime... i love your little notes at the bottom explaining everything and i find the back tracking interesting, it took me a while to catch on the the fact that we were in the past not still with kidnapped Charlie... threw me off. Thank you for this amazing writing and i look forward to more! your characters, situations and reactions are the most believable and "real" i have read in a long time!

Just found this - and you're already on chap 21 ... but it's good. Except for the 'little problem' with the latter chapters being out of sequence, which did throw me for a while - about half of a chapter actually (some days I'm not that bright). Love it though, please keep going. Purr